Smart Watch Buying Guide 2024: Apple Watch vs Galaxy Watch vs Fitbit and More

Smartwatches have evolved from glorified notification mirrors to sophisticated health monitors, fitness coaches, and lifestyle accessories. With so many options spanning $50 to $800+, choosing the right one can be overwhelming. Let's break down everything you need to know to make an informed decision.

What Can Modern Smartwatches Do?

Health & Fitness Tracking

• Heart rate monitoring (24/7)
• Sleep tracking and analysis
• Blood oxygen levels (SpO2)
• ECG (electrocardiogram) for heart health
• Stress and recovery tracking
• Menstrual cycle tracking
• Fall detection and emergency SOS

Activity Tracking

• Step counting and calories burned
• Automatic workout detection
• GPS for running, cycling, hiking
• Swimming tracking (water resistance)
• Guided workouts and coaching
• Personal records and achievements

Smart Features

• Smartphone notifications
• Calls and messages (with LTE models)
• Music storage and streaming
• Contactless payments
• Voice assistants
• App ecosystem

Lifestyle

• Watch face customization
• Interchangeable bands
• Always-on display options
• Fashion-forward designs
• Premium materials

The Flagship Contenders

Apple Watch Series 9 - $399+ (GPS) / $499+ (LTE)

Best for: iPhone users who want the complete ecosystem experience

Standout features:

• S9 chip with on-device Siri
• Double-tap gesture control
• Brightest display (2000 nits)
• Precision Finding for iPhone
• Comprehensive health tracking (ECG, blood oxygen, temperature)
• Massive app ecosystem
• Family Setup for kids without iPhones
• Crash detection and fall detection
• 18-hour battery life

Health features:

• ECG app (FDA cleared)
• Irregular heart rhythm notifications
• Blood oxygen monitoring
• Cycle tracking with temperature sensing
• Sleep stages tracking
• Mindfulness and stress tracking

The verdict: If you own an iPhone, this is the gold standard. The integration is unmatched, and the health features are comprehensive and accurate.

Drawbacks:

• Only works with iPhone
• Daily charging required
• Premium price

Choose this if: You're in the Apple ecosystem and want the best overall smartwatch experience

Apple Watch Ultra 2 - $799

Best for: Outdoor enthusiasts and extreme sports athletes

What makes it ultra:

• Titanium case (49mm)
• 3000-nit display (brightest ever)
• 36-hour battery life (72 hours in Low Power mode)
• Precision dual-frequency GPS
• 100m water resistance (diving capable)
• Action button for quick controls
• Siren for emergencies (86 decibels)
• Extreme temperature range (-20°C to 55°C)

Perfect for: Serious athletes, divers, hikers, adventurers who need rugged durability

Samsung Galaxy Watch 6 - $299+ (40mm) / $329+ (44mm)

Best for: Android users, especially Samsung phone owners

Standout features:

• Stunning AMOLED display
• Comprehensive health tracking
• Body composition analysis (BIA sensor)
• Sleep coaching with detailed insights
• Wear OS 4 with Google apps
• 40-hour battery life
• Rotating bezel (digital on Watch 6)
• Samsung ecosystem integration
• 5ATM water resistance

Health features:

• ECG and blood pressure monitoring (Samsung phones only)
• Blood oxygen monitoring
• Irregular heart rhythm notification
• Sleep tracking with sleep score
• Stress monitoring
• Skin temperature during sleep

The verdict: The best Android smartwatch, especially if you're in the Samsung ecosystem. Great balance of features, design, and battery life.

Drawbacks:

• Some features require Samsung phone
• Limited third-party app selection vs. Apple
• Blood pressure needs monthly calibration

Choose this if: You have an Android phone and want premium features

Samsung Galaxy Watch 6 Classic - $399+ (43mm) / $429+ (47mm)

Why it's special:

• Physical rotating bezel (fan favorite!)
• Premium stainless steel design
• Same features as Watch 6
• More traditional watch aesthetic

Perfect for: Those who prefer a more classic watch look with modern features

Google Pixel Watch 2 - $349 (WiFi) / $399 (LTE)

Best for: Google ecosystem fans and Fitbit users

Standout features:

• Seamless Google integration
• Fitbit health and fitness platform
• Stress management with body response tracking
• Continuous heart rate monitoring
• Safety Check with emergency sharing
• Improved battery life (24 hours)
• Snapdragon W5 chip (faster, more efficient)
• Premium circular design

Health features:

• ECG app
• Irregular heart rhythm notifications
• Skin temperature sensing
• Stress management
• Fitbit Premium integration (6 months free)
• Sleep tracking and sleep profile

The verdict: Beautiful design with Google's software polish and Fitbit's health expertise. Great for Android users who want something different from Samsung.

Drawbacks:

• Smaller 41mm size only
• Limited band options
• Daily charging

Choose this if: You love Google services and want Fitbit's health tracking

The Fitness-Focused Options

Garmin Forerunner 265 - $449

Best for: Serious runners and triathletes

Why athletes choose it:

• AMOLED display (new for Garmin)
• Up to 13 days battery life
• Advanced running dynamics
• Training readiness and recovery time
• Race predictor
• Multi-GNSS satellite support
• Detailed performance metrics
• Music storage

Training features:

• VO2 max estimation
• Training load and status
• Recovery time advisor
• Race time predictions
• Interval training
• Virtual pacer

The verdict: The best running watch on the market. If training data matters more than smart features, this is your watch.

Drawbacks:

• Limited smart features vs. Apple/Samsung
• Dated UI compared to competitors
• Smaller app ecosystem

Choose this if: You're a dedicated runner or triathlete who prioritizes training metrics

Garmin Epix Pro (Gen 2) - $899-$999

Best for: Multi-sport athletes and outdoor adventurers

Premium features:

• Stunning AMOLED display
• Up to 31 days battery life (smartwatch mode)
• 75 hours GPS battery
• Topographic maps
• Flashlight (LED)
• Advanced training metrics
• Expedition mode for multi-day adventures

Perfect for: Ultra-runners, mountaineers, multi-day hikers

Fitbit Sense 2 - $249

Best for: Health-conscious users on a budget

Standout features:

• Continuous EDA (stress) monitoring
• Skin temperature tracking
• ECG app
• Irregular heart rhythm notifications
• 6+ days battery life
• Lightweight and comfortable
• Fitbit Premium integration

Health focus:

• Stress management tools
• Mindfulness sessions
• Sleep tracking and sleep score
• Health metrics dashboard
• Menstrual health tracking

The verdict: Excellent health tracking at a reasonable price. Best for those prioritizing wellness over smart features.

Drawbacks:

• Limited third-party apps
• No voice assistant on watch
• Requires Fitbit Premium for many features ($10/month)

Choose this if: You want comprehensive health tracking without breaking the bank

The Budget Champions

Amazfit GTR 4 - $199

Best for: Budget-conscious buyers who won't compromise on features

Impressive specs:

• 1.43" AMOLED display
• Up to 14 days battery life
• Dual-band GPS
• 150+ sports modes
• Blood oxygen monitoring
• Sleep tracking
• Alexa built-in
• Offline voice assistant

The verdict: Incredible value. You're getting 80% of premium features at 30% of the cost.

Drawbacks:

• Less refined software
• Smaller app ecosystem
• Basic notification handling

Choose this if: You want great features without the premium price

Xiaomi Smart Band 8 Pro - $99

Best for: Fitness tracking on a tight budget

What you get:

• 1.74" AMOLED display
• Up to 14 days battery life
• Built-in GPS
• 150+ workout modes
• Heart rate and SpO2 monitoring
• Sleep tracking
• 5ATM water resistance

The verdict: Best fitness band on the market. Punches way above its price point.

Limitations:

• Basic smart features
• Small screen
• Limited app support

Choose this if: You primarily want fitness tracking and don't need extensive smart features

Fossil Gen 6 - $299 (often on sale for $199)

Best for: Fashion-conscious buyers who want traditional watch aesthetics

Why it stands out:

• Classic watch design
• Wear OS 3
• Interchangeable standard watch bands (22mm)
• Customizable watch faces
• Google Assistant and Alexa
• Rapid charging (80% in 30 minutes)

The verdict: Best looking smartwatch for those who prefer traditional watch styling.

Drawbacks:

• Older Snapdragon 4100+ chip
• Average battery life (24 hours)
• Limited health features

Choose this if: Style matters as much as function

Special Use Cases

For Kids: Apple Watch SE - $249

Why it's great for children:

• Family Setup (works without iPhone)
• Location tracking for parents
• Emergency SOS
• Activity tracking encourages movement
• Schooltime mode limits distractions
• Durable and water resistant

For Seniors: Samsung Galaxy Watch 5 - $279

Senior-friendly features:

• Large, clear display
• Fall detection
• Emergency SOS
• Simple interface
• Medication reminders
• Health monitoring

For Swimmers: Garmin Swim 2 - $249

Swimming-specific features:

• Pool and open water swimming
• Stroke detection
• SWOLF score
• Drill logging
• Underwater heart rate

For Style: Withings ScanWatch - $279

Hybrid smartwatch:

• Analog watch face
• Up to 30 days battery
• ECG and SpO2
• Sleep tracking
• Classic design
• Sapphire glass

Making Your Decision: A Framework

Step 1: Choose Your Ecosystem

iPhone user?

• Apple Watch Series 9 (best overall)
• Apple Watch SE (budget option)
• Apple Watch Ultra 2 (for adventurers)

Android user?

• Samsung Galaxy Watch 6 (best overall)
• Google Pixel Watch 2 (Google ecosystem)
• Garmin (fitness focus)
• Amazfit (budget option)

Step 2: Define Your Primary Use

General smartwatch features: Apple Watch Series 9 or Galaxy Watch 6 Serious fitness/training: Garmin Forerunner or Epix Health monitoring: Fitbit Sense 2 or Apple Watch Outdoor adventures: Apple Watch Ultra 2 or Garmin Epix Budget fitness: Amazfit or Xiaomi Style: Fossil Gen 6 or Withings

Step 3: Consider Battery Life

Daily charging acceptable:

• Apple Watch Series 9 (18 hours)
• Galaxy Watch 6 (40 hours)
• Pixel Watch 2 (24 hours)

Multi-day battery required:

• Garmin watches (7-31 days)
• Amazfit GTR 4 (14 days)
• Fitbit Sense 2 (6+ days)

Step 4: Set Your Budget

• Under $150: Xiaomi Smart Band 8 Pro, older Fitbit models
• $150-300: Fitbit Sense 2, Amazfit GTR 4, Apple Watch SE
• $300-450: Apple Watch Series 9, Galaxy Watch 6, Pixel Watch 2
• $450+: Apple Watch Ultra 2, Garmin Epix, premium models

Pro Tips for Smartwatch Owners

Maximize Battery Life

1. Reduce display brightness
2. Limit always-on display
3. Disable unnecessary notifications
4. Turn off continuous heart rate when not needed
5. Use battery saver mode during sleep

Get the Most Value

1. Buy previous generation at discount (still great)
2. Look for holiday sales
3. Consider certified refurbished
4. Check carrier deals (often free with phone purchase)
5. Buy third-party bands (much cheaper)

Maintenance

1. Clean regularly with damp cloth
2. Rinse after workouts
3. Remove at night occasionally (skin health)
4. Update software regularly
5. Replace bands when worn

Common Mistakes to Avoid

❌ Buying based on looks alone: Features and comfort matter more ❌ Ignoring ecosystem: iPhone users should choose Apple Watch ❌ Oversizing: Smaller wrists need smaller watches ❌ Forgetting LTE costs: Cellular plans add $10/month ❌ Skipping protection: Consider screen protectors for active use

The Bottom Line

The best smartwatch is the one that fits your lifestyle, ecosystem, and budget. There's no universal winner—only the right watch for you.

Quick recommendations:

• Best overall: Apple Watch Series 9 (iPhone) or Galaxy Watch 6 (Android)
• Best for fitness: Garmin Forerunner 265
• Best value: Amazfit GTR 4
• Best battery: Garmin Epix Pro
• Best for adventure: Apple Watch Ultra 2

Your wrist deserves a smart companion. Choose wisely and enjoy the connected life!

---

What smartwatch features matter most to you? Share your experiences below!